menu
The Hamptons
A Butler's Manor
Book Nowarrow_drop_down

Nearby Dining

Our restaurant reccomendations

The villages that comprise "The Hamptons" are fortunate to have a fine variety of good restaurants, some within walking distance of A Butler's Manor, running the gamut of very casual to fine dining. Kim and Chris take the testing of our local restaurants very seriously and try to eat out as often as possible to stay current with menu selections and new openings. A full binder of local menus is available for perusal in our living room, but here is a sample of places we most often recommend.

Plaza Cafe

Serene atmosphere & exceptional cuisine.

Plaza Cafe

Zagat & Wine Spectator Awards winner. Don't be fooled by the "cafe" — this is fine dining, and our favorite choice for a special dinner out, and out first choice for foodies. Seafood, fresh local fare, boutique American wines in a serene, sea blue dining room with vaulted ceilings.

631-283-9323 | website

Little Red

Casually upscale, classic café-style dining.

Little Red

Red Bar Brasserie's "little brother," Little Red presents a more casual experience (for example, no reservations) while still offering wonderful food. Very popular!

631-283-3309 | website

Red Bar Brasserie

An inspired balance of French influence and local bounty.

Red Bar Brasserie

Serving dinner 7 nights a week starting at 5:30, The Red Bar is an upscale & elegantly appointed spot serving New American-French fare by candlelight, often to a spirited set. One of the most comfortable gathering places for both Southampton locals and those who cherish fine dining. We highly recommend a reservation, especially during in-season.

631-283-0704 | website

Bell & Anchor

The restaurant pulls its inspiration from the rich history of Sag Harbor region: local seafood, steak, beer, vegetables.

Bell & Anchor

Bell & Anchor overlooks a small marina on Gardiner's Bay on Noyac Road, halfway between Sag Harbor and Southampton villages. It's off-the-beaten-track location carries through with a soft, laid-back vibe that feels nothing like some of the more frenetic restaurants in the villages. Soft sailcloth accents and lots of windows offer a spacious feeling, and the food is lovingly prepared.

631-725-3400 | website

Dockside Bar & Grill

Fun and casual environment with views of the harbor & inside or outside seating.

Dockside Bar & Grill

Don't let the fact that Dockside is located in the historic American Legion building stop you. Located on Bay Street, across the street from the marina, you can dine inside or out on good seafood and much more.

631-725-7100 | website

American Hotel

Creative dishes that bring the enticing flavors of France, Italy, America and Asia to the table.

American Hotel

Elegant dining with a 5-star wine list (the cellar occupies the entire footprint of the hotel). While no restaurant in the Hamptons including the American Hotel has a dress code, if you've brought your jacket or high heels, here's where you're most likely to wear them. If you're in the mood for caviar, this is the place! Reservations essential.

631-725-3535 | website

The Beacon

The best of the region's land & sea. All-inclusive flavor & texture. Local-made, but it sure doesn't taste like home.

The Beacon

The Beacon, located off West Water Street in Sag Harbor, offers marine-view dining overlooking Sag Harbor' Cove. It's open only in season and takes no reservations. Great sunset views!

631-725-7088 | website

Bobby Vans

Quintessential steakhouse rich in history & well-stocked by the best in bartender expertise.

Bobby Vans

Founded in 1969, Bobby Vans was originally renowned as the gathering place for such literary giants as James Jones and John Knowles. Bobby Van's is light and airy, with both indoor and outdoor dining options. Open seven days a week, you can expect old-school steakhouse fare and classic cocktails served in this laid back dining experience.

631-537-0590 | website

The 1770 House

Two options: sophisticated fine dining on the main floor or casual, traditional pub fare downstairs.

The 1770 House

Charming romantic restaurant with great food and service. Or for a complete change of pace, drop into the tavern downstairs for the casual pub menu and atmosphere!

631-324-1770 | website

TripAdvisor Certificate of Excellence 2017
Select Registry
Bespoke House
Instagram Facebook TripAdvisor